2024-04-12Leicester 0 – 1 Plymouth Argyle
2023-12-09Leicester 4 – 0 Plymouth Argyle
2010-02-20Leicester 1 – 1 Plymouth Argyle
2009-11-21Leicester 1 – 0 Plymouth Argyle
2008-02-09Leicester 0 – 1 Plymouth Argyle
2007-09-01Leicester 0 – 0 Plymouth Argyle
2007-04-09Leicester 0 – 3 Plymouth Argyle
2006-11-11Leicester 2 – 2 Plymouth Argyle