2026-05-24New York City FC 1 – 2 Nashville SC
2025-08-17New York City FC 2 – 1 Nashville SC
2025-05-31New York City FC 2 – 2 Nashville SC
2024-10-06New York City FC 3 – 1 Nashville SC
2024-06-23New York City FC 0 – 1 Nashville SC
2023-04-15New York City FC 2 – 1 Nashville SC
2023-02-25New York City FC 0 – 2 Nashville SC
2021-10-03New York City FC 0 – 0 Nashville SC